Yvonne Korshak reviews Off-Broadway, Broadway, Film and Art

Tag: Proust Page 1 of 2

Review | Waste of Time after Proust’s Remembrance of Things Past | Adapted by Robert David Macdonald | Classic Stage Company

… what a Waste of Time …

Over the epic course of generational time that marks Remembrance of Things Past, Proust charts subtle and ever evolving change in societal attitudes — the acceptance of modernity, and of democratic values.  Waste of Time gives only the slightest nod to this grand topic and immerses itself in gossip.

Did he sleep with her?  Did she sleep with her?  Did she sleep with him?  Did he sleep with him?  And what did they do when they did?  How do Lesbians manage?  etc.

Sure there are a few laughs, like any gossip.

It didn’t help that the actors seemed less practiced than in the two earlier, and far more effective, Proust adaptations — the actor playing Marcel, Proust’s stand-in, gave the impression he’d never seen the script before.  (For reviews of the first two adaptations, see: Swann in Love, and Albertine Regained).

You couldn’t glean that a monumental novel stands behind the dramatization.

Swann in Love will be presented again at Classic Stage in NYC’s East Village on April 13 — and that’s time well spent!

Review | Albertine Regained | after Proust’s Remembrance of Things Past | Adapted by Pamela Hansford Johnson | Directed by Michael Sexton | Classic Stage Company

… Proust II …

Albertine Regained, the second in Classic Stage’s Proust Project, isn’t as compelling as Swann in Love (reviewed directly above) because, though well acted, it’s not as good a story.  Motivations are unclear:  why on earth is Albertine, a young girl on a holiday with her friends at the beach, so drawn to the lethargic, “thin armed” Marcel?  especially since she has an eager, suitable and equally wealthy suitor right at hand, Bloch.  He may not be sufficiently sensitive for her taste but Marcel isn’t characterized as having any competitive advantage on his side.  And Marcel’s way of “loving” Albertine, confining her in a stuffy house, and not making love to her, is so equivocal that it’s hard to see it as “love” in the romantic and passionate sense the characters use the word.
Just as Swann marries Odette when he has ceased to love her, so Marcel marries Albertine when, he says, he no longer loves her.  Ah love’s perversities — Proust follows them with the subtlety of a fine line drawing, loving them more than love itself.  You can tell Proust knew this story needed something extra — he introduces a female Iago character (that’s how he describes her) to keep things interesting but that character doesn’t quite do the trick, just lets you know the author saw the problem.

Albertine Regained does, however, have its own competitive advantage.  In several stunning passages Proust, painting with a full brush and color palette, uses images from the outer world to convey inner states of mind.  In that new territory opened up for exploration in the early Twentieth Century — the inner landscape — he was a great pioneer.

Albertine Regained was presented at Classic Stage March 30. Still to come in the Proust Project series based on Remembrance of Things Past is Waste of Time on April 6, and Encore: Swann in Love on April 13.

Page 1 of 2

Powered by WordPress & Theme by Anders Norén