Let's Talk Off Broadway

Yvonne Korshak reviews Off-Broadway, Broadway, Film and Art

Austin Pendleton as Paul and Eric Joshua Davis as David

REVIEW Consider the Lilies | Written and Directed by Stuart Fail | House Red Theatre Company

… Socrates and Alcibiades? …

I wanted to see Consider the Lilies because Austin Pendleton is such a fascinating actor to watch:  he didn’t disappoint here, but he’s the main element of interest. (Pendleton is also a fine director, though he didn’t direct this play.)

Austin Pendleton as Paul and Eric Joshua Davis as David

L-R Austin Pendleton as Paul and Eric Joshua Davis as David. Photo Talya Chalef

This is basically a two-person play. Paul an elderly, talented painter (Pendleton) has lost his creative way, while a young man, his agent, David (Eric Joshua Davis) believes in him and urges him to produce more paintings.  They’re in Paris for a gallery opening David has arranged for Paul’s painting.  The play centers around the artist and agent but – far more than business – their relationship is one of complex bonding and emotional dependency.  As old and scruffy as he is, Paul, who is bi-sexual is seeking to seduce David who’s sure he isn’t gay (though Paul thinks he knows better.)

A question that runs through ones mind while watching the play:  can such a scruffy, unkempt-to-verging-on-repulsive old man really think he can seduce such a good-looking young guy?  We’re talking not just about bedding down but falling in love.

Austin Pendleton and Eric Joshua Davis. Photo Talya Chalef

Austin Pendleton and Eric Joshua Davis. Photo Talya Chalef

The idea has excellent credentials and goes back a long way.  Think of the beautiful, young (and rich and aristocratic) Alcibiades enamored of ugly, old Socrates in Plato’s Symposium.   An iconic example in modern theater is the seduction of a young writer by the powerfully willed, tubercular old man in Tennessee Williams’ great play, Vieux Carre, which Pendleton directed a few years back in a Pearl Theater production.  And recently Pendleton acted in a role similar to Paul, in Ira Lewis’ Chinese Coffee – and old and seductive mentor to a handsome young man, though here it’s the younger man who has the genuine talent.

With his irony, oddly misplaced smiles, and his way of pinning down the truths of emotional moments, Pendleton in Consider the Lilies comes close to making us believe it could happen here, too, though he’s so aggressively unkempt, dry and wispy erotic love is a bigger stretch.

The characters are given to repeating in claustrophobic loops rather than advancing.  Themes are introduced such as abandoned children and uncaring parents, and new characters are brought in to keep the drama going:  a violent thief, a successful painter-of-the-moment who gives Paul some tips, and an unfaithful girl-friend, but the situations and language veer toward commonplace (the play could benefit from a red pencil).  The resolution is arbitrary, whether you see it as positive or negative.

Consider the Lilies plays at TBG Theatre in Manhattan’s Chelsea district through January 28, 2017.  For more information and tickets, click here.

Yvonne Korshak

Comments are very welcome.  Scroll down to read comments or to make your own.  Thank you.

Previous

REVIEW The Band’s Visit | Music & Lyrics by David Yazbek | Book by Itamar Moses | Atlantic Theater Company

Next

REVIEW   Albatross | By Matthew Spangler and Benjamin Evett | Starring Benjamin Evett | Inspired by “The Rime of the Ancient Mariner” by Samuel Taylor Coleridge

2 Comments

  1. Oscar

    I sat through this travesty of a play. Although Pendleton was good – that’s where the evening began and ended. The various intended plots are fabricated, the emotions are basic soap opera and all in all it was an evening to forget.

  2. Jay

    How long was this play? Entirely toooooo long. Even Pendleton has a finite number of palettes.

Leave a Reply

Powered by WordPress & Theme by Anders Norén